Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Shane45

Premier Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Shane45

  1. Luis, yer on the IDPA / Practical Multigun side of the fence bro! At least thats the competitions I see you at!
  2. Im game and this isnt the first time I tried to put together force on force. Wheres Wojo? He was interested in instructing a session! BUT I aint doing it with Ray Ray! Hes got a bayonette on his pistol, and well, thats just not fair ROFL.
  3. Slav, as usual your missing the point and clearly havent read all the posts. If its worth repeating several times, whats one more... No douubt gun handling and stress indoc are advantages gained by just about any competitive shooting as has been said repeatedly in this thread. The concern is if you only shoot a type of competition A LOT more than training or other types that it would likely be an issue because under real stress you will do what you did most. So if you shoot a metric ton of USPSA and your used to just popping out into the open, you might do that very same thing in a real situation. Or you might go out in the open while reloading or you might go through mags like water because your used to having 4......
  4. Here ya go Ray Ray. In IDPA you always shoot from cover if available.
  5. Ray Ray, you sure your not confusing USPSA with IDPA. IDPA is pretty much a stock gun competition. Its 90% bone stock sigs and glocks. And in fact some IDPA matches have a BUG side match. (BUG=Back up gun) And it has to be an actual subcompact or revolver. And in IDPA its always in cover and tactical (except for a qualifier match where you dont have to wear a cover garment which I actually never understood)
  6. Vlad, ya kind of sound like the cigarette comapanies demanding proof cigarettes cause cancer. So you need the examiner that was so astute he was able to put together the guy that stood out in the open and took one to the brain bucket and conclude it was the type of comps he was shooting......ok sure. Even though every real trainer out there will express this concern you need more proof. I think you are now back peddling. No one said games are a substitute for training. Your example of new shooters makes no sense because they havent done it enough to develop the programmed responce so clearly that is not what we are talking about. We are talking about shooters that do a lot of competing in specific types of competition, but I believe you know that. How can you say you absolutely believe its a concern and in the same paragraph demand proof???
  7. Jack just I dont know your level of experience so dont take offence if I am telling you stuff you already know. But for example in USPSA the object is really speed. And as such there is NO consideration for cover. Your pretty much always shooting in the open, reloading in the open etc etc. Now Im not saying IDPA is perfect because its not. BUT, you always engage from cover when available. You get a penalty if you dont. You cant leave cover with an empty weapon. You will get a penalty if you do. etc etc. The rule set are more in line with tactics that you would want to use. Some on this board know Gene whom was a trainer from an org that everyone knows. He's LE and does EP. Ever watch him shoot a glock match? He still employs cover etc etc because he does not want to develop bad habits for obvious reasons.
  8. I just wanted to add this, if I had to get dropped in the middle of beruit, Id rather have someone that shoots any gun game with me because they have weapons handling experience and some handling weapons under stress indoc over someone that has just shot on a static square range. Id rather have an IDPA competitor/Practical multigun over USPSA/3Gun. Id rather have Polite society over IDPA. Id ratehr have someone thats been to a number of schools over a competitor. Id rather have someone that shoots IDPA/Polite society/prac multigun AND does schools over all afformentioned.
  9. Vlad, weapons handling is not in question. I KNOW I owe my speed with a 1911 to my time in IPSC. thats not what we are talking about here. So lets clarify, your line of questions gives the impression that you dont believe its a concern. But I dont want to debate on assumptions, id rather hear you say thats your stated position because it looks like your back peddling a little bit. Jack, thats a cover/concealment topic and actually something addressed at most schools and some types of competition.
  10. Vlad, why do you refuse to see the correlation between what you do most, you will do when you go on autopilot... This is taught at just about every training facility in the country yet you doubt it. that defies logic. Unless of course you know something the entire weapons training community doesnt.
  11. Vlad, this ones for you buddy: How does competitive shooting relate to the kind of skills necessary for law enforcement and personal defense? "You have to learn the distinctive difference between competitive shooting and real world tactical shooting," "There are some bad habits you can develop by shooting a lot of tournaments. However, if you focus on the fundamentals--weapons handling, weapons manipulation and marksmanship--you are in a much higher echelon." .....JJ Racaza
  12. NJ2A, I think your misreading it. Being in a protracted fight is not the concern, unless you happen to have been in Katrina or the LA riots. Protracted firefight experience was a req for being an instructor in certain circles.
  13. Vlad would it make you feel better if I took the 4 letter word game out of it and changed it to bad habits? Did you even read the article? You really dont see the correlation? So anyone that shoots USPSA and gets shot standing out in the open, can I call that an example?
  14. A discussion in another thread lead down the path of this discusion. I have ALWAYS believed theres a corellation between subconscious stimulus – response patterns that you WILL develop in the repetition of competitions like USPSA/3gun and what the pre programmed responce will be under the stress induced responce of a real life incident. As a result I changed what gun games I will shoot because I dont want to be in the habit of doing things like standing in the open, reloading outside of cover, or using equipment that is not real useful outside of the game its self. This is NOT to impeach gun games at all. Its simply a discussion on the topic. My original origins in the shooting sports are from NRA Action Pistol and IPSC. But I switched to things like IDPA and Practical Multigun to stop instilling habits I dont want to ingrain in myself. I got more penalties for not getting behind cover in IDPA than actual targets engaged! But for those that like to race guns, I love that you do and I love to watch. Although not specifically gun games this article illustrates the point of what you do ...is what you will do. http://www.killology.com/on_combat_ch2.htm But why are gamers employed to teach you say? What needs to be understand is that the Rob leathem's, JJ Racazza's, Todd Jarret's of the world who obtained their fame in Gun Games but are employed to train real deal people is that these people are at a level where they litteraly have a mental switch in their head that they can switch between venues because they do ALL OF IT so much. The other thing to know is that who they train only goes so high. There IS a next level of training that frankly, to get there as a trainer you need credentials of real life protracted fire fights or your not invited.
  15. If a rifle Im putting my money on the SCAR.
  16. No Old School, you can meet me in my driveway. And take this freeking heavy a$$ lathe with you when you go, even if it is to small !!!!! Since this thread is sidetracked beyond all recognition, again, the speed of projo's from barrels is highly subjective. And again, with match/quality barrels, the speed diff just aint there. For example, knights SR25 is getting in many cases LESS THAN 50fps difference between their 20" barrel and their 16" barrel!!! This is why you see a MAJOR push from most top tier mnufacturers to focus on 16" guns. There is little poiont to carry the extra weight of a 20 anymore. Apply that to 14.5 vs 16 and it could come down to which barrel is faster. I Bet you I can find a poly rifled 14.5 that can clock faster than most 16's....
  17. Roger that, replied and gave ya my cell cuz I hate/suck at typing
  18. Vlad, its not an assumption, its an impression AND STATED AS SO. Gun games is the impression you guys give me. What I dont understand is why you take that as a knock. If its not the case why wouldnt a simple, "no shane we agree our rifles are set up with the same train of thought as you" be presented. Instead you guys seem predisposed to take offence. I can tell you that one of my 1911's is a defacto gun game pistol. It was setup to shoot open class IPSC in the late 90's. I would take no offence at all if someone called it a gamer pistol. It is. It was set up to give me the advantage in that game. I think my point was fairly simple. It was that I wouldnt modify my fighting gun for any game but I would compete with it. I have the IMPRESSION that you guys give more priority to the game. Why would that be taken as a negative? If I where much more serious about 3 gun type competitions you can damn well bet i would have rifles dedicated to that end. They would be optimised for the game. And I would take NO offence if someone said they were game guns. Its not a BAD thing to be more comitted to a discipline of competition than me, honestly! I use competitions as my practice sessions. Im a highly competitive person but I lack the time and comittment to be compettitive. So MY focus remains rudimentary. Do you think I am not giveng competition its due credit for developing battle worthy solutions? I can tell you for a fact that the military pays a lot of attention to what goes on in the gun game world as there is more than a casual overlap there. There are are very good articles by Zak Smith out there on that very topic. Frankly Im not sensitive about my equipment. In fact I have no emotional investment in any of it. It would seem Im in the minority on that. I could care less what ANYONE holds as an opinion of what I run. It works for me. That is all thats important. Something else I have often stated, use what works for you and what you have confidence in as that is what likely to be most effective for you since firearms are largely a personal matter. Vlad/Slav I think one of the things you are missing, when I state an impression Im getting, in essance Im asking what you run. But as I review the thread, I dont see any information. Only questions and challanges about how others have their equipment set up. I think its a fair statement that the impressions are clear by comments made such as: "And what is the fetish with the stubby barrel? " "Aside from that, it does not have a free float handguard." "Aha...so what is the advantage of a short barrel for anyone not planning to go kicking in doors in Falluja?" " If you were shooting from vehicles a lot I'd understand" And this gets to the very core of my position. My rifle is set up so that if I ever had to do any of these things, that is the rifles focus. Based on these comments it would seem rather clear you disagree with this focus. However, this is not a knock on your position, simply that it appears to be different than mine. But for the life of me I cant figure out the lack of humility position. I would love it if someone could explain this. I have what I have, I do what I do, I have access to people and things many do not. Everything I discuss is MY perspective or take or experience or first hand knowledge. If the board would prefer I didnt share any of this information so I can keep up humble appearances, I can surely do so. If I discuss the S&B short dot 1.1X8 I got to play with of which there were only like 3 in the country at the time, and I give my impressions and what I didnt like, are you taking that as bragging, or usefull info?
  19. Toss old buddy I think we are going to disagree on this one. If the bg is in front of my kids room, Im not taking the shot. Id rather hope I can either take the hit and fight on or hope he misses and I can maneuver to a firing position. But of course in my home I already know my safe fire zones. I truly believe if you spotted someone in the fire zone, you wouldnt take the shot either. I think you are oversimplifying the decision process in this discussion. But then again, you went to public school...
  20. Not sure where tosser was going there as I know he is well aware of backstop, but backstop is always a consideration.
  21. Im exceedingly happy with my off the shelf colt. It does have a different brake on it but thats it. Will likely drop a Gieselle in it at some point but other than that, she runs like a raped ape! Slav, I think that I am safe in saying that a number of people in this thread like Tosser, Joel and Cylinder Head may use their rifles for gun games or classes or what have you BUT even if a config thats different than what they have might work better in a game, I bet, like me, they would not change the rifle. Because in the end, god forbid, the rifles are set up to work in the real world. Because the rifle is the insurance policy if ever everything should go wrong. That is its most basic role. Everything else we do with them is a bonus. I suspect for you the opposite is true. You focus your rifle around the needs of the sport you use it for. Thats fine but I bet that your rifle config may end up being a bit different than ours.
  22. Because they are moving so fast, they tend to frag very quickly. I havent done the research on this round specifically but knowing the good Doc, he has certainly taken it into consideration. Generally speaking rounds of this type have proven to have far less penetration than pistol or shotgun.
  23. http://www.m4carbine.net/showthread.php?t=75298 3100fps out of a 14" barrel. This is the type of round I would use for HD from a rifle.
  24. Golf clubs gentlemen. Rifles are golf clubs. Some are specialised like a pitching wedge or a driver, some are of broader use like a 5 iron So the 26" free float 6.5 grendal AR is your driver! The 12" SBR (I know, not in NJ but I'm making a point here) is your pitching wedge. A 16" lightweight ar is your 5 iron capable of a broader spectrum of usefullness. I believe in having a complete and full golf bag But I prefer my 5 iron On the topic of barrels, velocity and cartidge effectiveness: In high end ar's we are usually talking custom barrels. Custom barrels dont seem to play by the same velocity rules as factory barrels. The velocity loss is not standard!!! This is likely due to the rifling, hand lapping, and bore uniformity throughout its entire length of the custom barrel. I have seen exceptionally small differences in velocity from barrels as far appart as 16 vs 20. I would also like to repeat(as I often do) that YOU CAN NOT JUDGE 5.56 effectiveness based on military observations!!! That rhetoric is so often repeated it gets engrained in everyones mind but its so often forgotten or overlooked that we as civilians are NOT restricted to military ammo. There are plenty of 5.56 shooting out of short rifles with commercial ammo in use by law enforcement that there is little question to its effectiveness.
  25. I was expecting to see a sport bike up on one

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.