Everything posted by jackandjill
- Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
-
Supreme Court takes up straw purchase conviction case
Same here. At the least, it provided fuel to the Sotomayor and team.
-
Supreme Court takes up straw purchase conviction case
Interesting. Were lawmakers just being generous or some other reason behind gift being exempted from straw purchase rule ?
-
Supreme Court takes up straw purchase conviction case
Cases like this remind me that its more about letter of the law than spirit of the law. And even SCOTUS will legislate from the bench. Not long ago, call it panic buying or newbie stupidity/anxiety, I ended up paying for two of same model firearms. Instead of taking possession at FFL, tried to have someone else take it (with proper paperwork etc) for their own enjoyment because that was the right thing (in the letter of the law) to do. Ended up with interesting situation at FFL. Anyways, many recommended that I should have just taken the possession and "do whatever I wanted afterwards". Glad I did not. ---------- On a related note, had this been gift, would the outcome be same ?
-
Supreme Court takes up straw purchase conviction case
I stand corrected. Thanks.
-
Gun laws and the 2nd amendment
Prohibition effort didnt stop even when everyone knew that everyone and their dog was drinking. It took corrupted police forces, uprise of bootlegger & mafia and countless deaths before it was repealed. In summary, I dont think we can underestimate stupidity of some people and lengths they go given the power.
-
Supreme Court takes up straw purchase conviction case
I dont think he (Abramski) was selling through FFL. Abramski was really arguing that this whole "straw purchase" argument has to go away and its none of anyones business what happens to the firearm after the purchaser walks away from that counter.
-
Supreme Court takes up straw purchase conviction case
As I read it, Abramski pushed for arguing the whole things as moot i.e shouldnt matter even IF the other person is prohibited or not.
-
Supreme Court takes up straw purchase conviction case
" But Abramski now focuses on a new and more ambitious argument, which he concedes no court has previously accepted. See Brief for Petitioner i.3.In brief, he alleges that a false response to Question 11.a. is never material to a gun sale’s legality, whether or not the actual buyer is eligible to own a gun. We begin with that fundamental question, " Looks like Abramski tried to make this 2A issue by challenging the legality (or the material value) of the information presented in that form.
-
A-3284
Which is on the agenda anyways. In PRNJ, the end result could be same, but which one is better ? Propose bill that makes Dems look bad or Propose a bill that had 50 items listed ?
-
A-3284
Agreed, but couldnt an argument be made that DUE to awb, the Dems are actually enabling more accurate, "evil" weapons. Hence the flash suppressor should be remove from "two or more" clause ?
-
A-3284
We need bills that would corner the other side. I know its difficult but they have to tie the benefits to either children, criminals or 'reducing" effectiveness of firearms in general. I dont claim to know much about anything, but how about a bill to remove the flash suppressor limitation. Isnt it that muzzle devices stabilize better and make firearms more accurate ? Who from Gum Control side wants more accurate firearms ? Aren't there any creative, dump-on-other-side ideas that can be turned into bills ?
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
Could it then be argued that there will never be a "straight" 2A case from NJ ? It appears that NJ played very well with its laws. One can keep and one could bear arms according to NJ laws. So no straight denial of 2A rights. If someone did manage to get to SCOTUS, could it be argued that NJ (technically) allows carry of long arms with just FPID and no additional permits ? Even if someone from a ' no issue" state bring the case to SCOTUS and win, it may not affect NJ laws in any form or content because, technically, we are allowed to carry. In my limited knowledge, I cannot see a straight NJ case getting to SCOTUS and winning nor do I see any decisions from any other state challenging current NJ laws.
-
No Guns At Chipolte
We are having a debate here and no one is trying make sensational bullshit. I have seen such setup in subways, midtown manhattan etc. No one is questioning the purpose or the manner in which these officers are carrying. And there is no debate on those two idiots posing for pics or their wannabe gangsta pics elsewhere. Thats not the point. The point is about hippocratic arguments around general OC of rifles. If someone cannot swallow the fact that others can exercise their "keep and bear arms" right, then go join the groups that are intent on winning the hearts and minds of people and ban assault looking weapons or requiring "justifiable need" or plethora of other feel good, think-of-children measures. Lets pause, write down our own arguments against OC of rifles and read them loud. They sound awfully similar to anti arguments in one form or other. And there is no sensational bullshit in that statement. Peace.
-
No Guns At Chipolte
Couldnt have said any better. Why are people are ok with these "low ready", armed to teeth, Baghdad style patrol troops but not with people who do OC legally ? Folks who are complaining about the two idiots (yes they are, for doing stupid poses), would you be ok if someone dresses up like these fine gentlemen here and show up in Chipolte ? That should pass your "dress properly" criteria ? It takes a LOT (really LOT) to stand for the rights of everyone and not let your personal preferences or subjective, convenient interpretations cloud your judgement. Remember, one should do time if they do crime. Anything else should be fair game. I-am-responsible-but-not-others attitude is why 2A will be dead in letter and spirit sooner or later.
- Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
-
NJ FID/PP Compliancy Project
Applied for P2P on 05/15/2014. 212A was submitted via paper (not online) and just got NJSP name check back (212A). Took about 3 weeks. FYI. Now waiting for the local PD to review and type the P2Ps.
-
SCOTUS denies Kwong v DeBlasio (SAF suit against permit fees)
Just for the kicks, SCOTUS has been so busy with "other" important things such as... wait for it...... ------------ Supreme Court to Hear T-Mobile Cell-Tower Case Justices to Decide If Local Governments Must Give Detailed Written Reasons When Towers Denied The court will hear an appeal by a T-Mobile US Inc.TMUS -1.01% subsidiary that was turned away for a permit in Roswell, Ga. The company said certain city council members raised various objections to the T-Mobile tower proposal and voted it down. But the city never provided an official written explanation for the denial, the company argued. ------------
-
SCOTUS denies Kwong v DeBlasio (SAF suit against permit fees)
We can agree to disagree. Practically being a "legislated right" is not an excuse for SCOTUS to continue ducking on the issue. SCOTUS reminding us to exercise our voting power is good imagination at best. Going out and voting is all dandy. But if Voting is the ONLY recourse, minority will always lose (not just on 2A) and no need for SCOTUS.
-
SCOTUS denies Kwong v DeBlasio (SAF suit against permit fees)
No one (largely) goes out to elect irresponsible, dishonest office holders. Even the scum of the scum is elected because the majority (right or wrong) looked at them as responsible and honest. When a dispute is not resolved through lower courts (or there is split), it the job (atleast expectation) of the SCOTUS to listen and rule based on rule of the land, of which CONSTITUTION is THE Supreme Law. I like to see if SCOTUS will deny cert if the case was about everyone having to pay $10 much less $340 + 100 for FP for a right to vote or even drivers license. Someone should not be able to make it prohibitively expensive to exercise rights, specially the ones that goes to protection of life. There are standards and way to measure what is "prohibitive".
-
My Rant of the day on mag limits bill A2006/S993
Most of us resigned to fact that NJ is a lost cause. NRA is resigned to that same conclusion. So that leaves us with either Federal laws, NJ cases winning at SCOTUS or Some other cases winning at SCOTUS. Winning cases at SCOTUS takes years, then NJ throws a wrench, back to courts and more years. By the time we really get something, most of us will be turning in our graves. Here is what bothers. With all due respect, when is the last time Republicans advanced 2A rights at the Federal level ? Last administration could get Patriot Act passed but not a national concealed carry ? Just venting...
-
Bad Dream: What would you have done?
Confess that you were at MIL to rob them at gun(s) point. Plead the gun charges away in exchange for community service ? :-) .....Just Kidding
-
Firearms as collection / investment
Thanks everyone. Great suggestions and insights. I have few PPs coming in. Will ask specific recommendations on respective thread.
-
Firearms as collection / investment
Not to hold for 10 years :-), but got them for the pleasure of loading (and learning). So covered.
-
Firearms as collection / investment
I dont hunt but like to shoot various firearms for the fun of it and importance of keeping 2A alive. I am not looking for safe queens. Want something that I can shoot, learn, enjoy and keep the value and tradition going. I watched various videos of "5 guns everyone should own", got them and shooting them. Looking for the next fix :-) if you will. I know the question is very generic (like asking where to buy a house) but hoping to learn from others here.