686 plus or saiga 223?

[7-3-2 9]

Not sure if you all go through this or not as often as I do but I always battling between 2 or 3 different toys when it come time to drop the coin.

 

I was saving for my permit to come in and was going to grab a 686 plus but recently found out that my LGS got a few Saiga 223 rifles in. Here I am now wondering what to do,  spend the money Ive been saving on the saiga or just keep its moving and keep saving for the 686. 

 

Pros for the 686+

 

I don't have a wheelie outside of my sp101 22lr 

It would be my go to HD piece

They are GORGEOUS!

I always want the 357 but always end up buying something else

 

Pros for the Saiga

 

I already have an AR in 5.56 so I already have the ammo needed

I have a chance to get it while I still can (revolvers won't be banned anytime soon)

I could use another rifle as my AR and my 10/22 are all I have now

Its always a great idea to learn how to use a new platform effectively

 

Any advice? As of right now Im leaning towards the Saiga just because like I said above, the saiga might not always be obtainable in this State/Country while I can always get my hands on a revolver in the future.

 

[illy 1]

[7-3-2 9]

LOL, its just too easy. I wish I could come across a lump sum of money and then spend it all on new toys. Id probably still want more though, it always seems like I just want two or three more than I have no matter how many I buy lol.

[ogfarmer 138]

Saiga since their future is unknown at this point. Bullseye Tactical got a bunch in over the weekend.

[7-3-2 9]

Saiga since their future is unknown at this point. Bullseye Tactical got a bunch in over the weekend

Bingo on the location … and shhhh one of those might be mine!

[alec.mc 180]

686, skip the 7 shot shot version and get the 6, or, go for the 8 shot .357 and get the 627

[Vlad G 345]

Get the 686, and I say that as someone who doesn't own a single revolver or care to.

 

You already have a rifle, the Saiga would add a second string to the AR, you are never going to shoot both equally. I've shot Saiga's, they work but they are meh.

 

If they ban Saigas, they won't let you keep it anyway

 

What you really want is a 686 but you keep getting distracted. Well .. stop that. Focus, buy the 686, and see what you really want to get as the "next' thing.

[gleninjersey 2,141]

Get the Smith. You won't rever regret it. And I'm a Ruger guy!

[jm1827 284]

Get the Smith, great choice.  My first gun purchase ever was a 686, bought it as soon as I turned 21, and to this day it is my favorite gun to shoot!

[lunker 274]

If they ban Saigas, they won't let you keep it anyway

 

What you really want is a 686 but you keep getting distracted. Well .. stop that. Focus, buy the 686, and see what you really want to get as the "next' thing.

On the first point, the ban is simply on importation. So Saigas will always be obtainable (barring a gun control AK ban), but at an increasing cost. And remember that there are plenty of non-Russian AK's whose quality is comparable with Russian, and they are not on the importation ban. 

The second point is dead on. Take it from someone with the firearms attention span of a puppy on speed, 90% of impulse gun purchases end up getting sold in the end (often at a loss). Focus on what you like. Experiment with other people's purchases and see if it's a "love story". If so, then consider making your own purchase. It will save you money, time and hassle. 

[Bully 749]

Me, I'd get the 686. Great gun.

 

AK style guns in .223 just don't excite me. Plus, although all guns are fun, only accurate guns are interesting. Go for the Smith.

 

C

[TonyS. 12]

GP100.      The Smith supposedly has a better trigger but I like the GP100 ergos and 3-point lockup better than the Smith. The 686+ is a helluva beauty though.

[7-3-2 9]

I love the GP100 as well and its right there neck and neck with the 686 imo but the extra round really makes the 686 plus appealing to me .. and the looks/finish

[tommyfeds 2]

Maybe this will help............

 

  

[svt3183 14]

Put a spring kit in the gp100 and it goes from great to amazing.

 

Remixer has a 686+ at this moment.

 

I love the GP100 as well and its right there neck and neck with the 686 imo but the extra round really makes the 686 plus appealing to me .. and the looks/finish

[7-3-2 9]

So just to let everyone know, I did end up putting a down payment on a 686+ last night ... now the ball is in Edison PD's court about when they want to get my permit ready. Thanks for all the direction guys, you saved me from making and impulse buy.

[Purple Patrick 638]

You made the better choice. My 686+ was the first pistol i bought and i love it.

[SW9racer 262]

Great choice! My first handgun was a 686 4" in stainless. I long sold it off as my interest shifted to semi, but I am glad I started on it, and learned to reload my own ammo with it.

[bennj 215]

Get the 686. I have a GP100 and love shooting it, but I WILL own a 686 some day!

[Knuckle Sandwich 5]

On the first point, the ban is simply on importation. So Saigas will always be obtainable (barring a gun control AK ban), but at an increasing cost. And remember that there are plenty of non-Russian AK's whose quality is comparable with Russian, and they are not on the importation ban. 

The second point is dead on. Take it from someone with the firearms attention span of a puppy on speed, 90% of impulse gun purchases end up getting sold in the end (often at a loss). Focus on what you like. Experiment with other people's purchases and see if it's a "love story". If so, then consider making your own purchase. It will save you money, time and hassle. 

 

I don't have a link to support this, but the word on the street is Kalashnikov Concern was bought out, and will circumvent Obummer's BS importation ban. The dealers are allegedly holding their stock trying to get as much for them as they can while people still think Saiga's are verboten.

 

OP get the 686 and wait for the Saiga market bottom to drop out. edit: OP already made the right choice

 

edit: http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2014/09/foghorn/kalashnikov-concern-plans-skirt-us-import-ban-selling-company/

[7-3-2 9]

I was going to do this actually, or just buy a lower and build another AR instead. I definitely feel like I made the right choice by going with the 686 though.

[jermz1987 243]

Great choice, I would have gone with the 686 as well.